Check out our most popular compounded medications! Get Started

Sildenafil vs tadalafil tablets: how the two compare

Using Your Medication
Using Your Medication
The Bayview Team
Updated on
11/20/2026 10:05 AM
•
4 min read
Pharmacist reviewedMedically reviewed by
Ryan Dyer, RPh.
Bayview Pharmacy vials of sildenafil tablets and tadalafil tablets on a desk beside a man writing questions
Sildenafil vs tadalafil tablets: how the two compare
Sildenafil and tadalafil tablets work the same way but differ in how long the effect lasts and how they can be scheduled. A side-by-side comparison, with the same price for both at Bayview.
Ryan Dyer, RPh.
false
November 20, 2026
Sildenafil Tablets
Patients
Key takeaways
  • Both tablets are FDA-approved PDE5 inhibitors.
  • Tadalafil's effect window is longer, up to 36 hours.
  • Tadalafil can also be prescribed as a small daily dose.
  • Neither can be combined with nitrate medications.
  • Both are $30 for 30 tablets at Bayview.
In this article

Sildenafil and tadalafil are the two most prescribed tablets for erectile dysfunction. Both are FDA-approved generics, both belong to the same drug class, and Bayview Pharmacy dispenses both: Sildenafil Tablets and Tadalafil Tablets. Which one fits is your prescriber's decision. This comparison explains what they will be weighing.

How are sildenafil and tadalafil alike?

Both are PDE5 inhibitors. They support blood flow in response to sexual stimulation, and neither works without it. They share the same most important warning: neither can be taken with nitrate medications.

A man talking with his doctor in an exam room

How do they differ?

PointSildenafil tabletsTadalafil tablets
Strengths at Bayview20, 25, 50, 100 mg5, 10, 20 mg
Usual labeled starting dose50 mg as needed10 mg as needed
When it is takenAbout 1 hour before activityBefore activity, or once daily
Effect windowHoursUp to 36 hours
Daily low-dose optionNoYes, 2.5 to 5 mg
FoodA high-fat meal can delay itTaken without regard to food
Other approved usePulmonary arterial hypertension (20 mg)Enlarged prostate symptoms (5 mg daily)
Price at Bayview30 for $3030 for $30

When might a prescriber choose one over the other?

  • Timing. Sildenafil suits a planned dose. Tadalafil's longer window leaves more room.
  • A daily routine. Tadalafil can be prescribed as a small dose every day, with no timing around activity.
  • Prostate symptoms. Tadalafil 5 mg daily is also approved for the symptoms of an enlarged prostate.
  • Side effects. Both can cause headache, flushing, indigestion and congestion. Vision changes are listed more often with sildenafil, and back pain and muscle aches with tadalafil.

The two are not taken together.

A couple loading weekend bags into their car on an autumn morning

What safety rules apply to both?

Do not take either with nitrates such as nitroglycerin or isosorbide, or with riociguat. Tell your prescriber about heart disease, blood pressure medications and alpha-blockers. Get emergency care for an erection lasting more than four hours, or for sudden loss of vision or hearing.

What if neither tablet works well enough?

Tell your prescriber. Dose and timing are often adjusted first. If tablets are still not enough, prescribers may move to injections such as alprostadil, papaverine and phentolamine injection, which Bayview compounds on a prescription. They may also check testosterone, and if it is low, consider options such as enclomiphene.

What do they cost at Bayview?

Both tablets share one price schedule in every strength: 30 tablets for $30, 60 for $37 and 90 for $48. Patients enrolled in Auto Refills save 15% on every fill.

Frequently asked questions

No items found.

References

Sources reviewed

The medical information in this article draws on the following sources.

  1. DailyMed, National Library of Medicine. Sildenafil tablets, film coated: Prescribing Information.
  2. DailyMed, National Library of Medicine. Tadalafil tablets, film coated: Prescribing Information.
  3. Burnett AL, Nehra A, Breau RH, et al. Erectile Dysfunction: AUA Guideline. J Urol. 2018;200(3):633-641.

What Bayview compounds for this

Important: Compounded medications are prepared to a prescriber's order for an individual patient. They are not FDA-approved, and the FDA has not evaluated them for safety, effectiveness, or manufacturing quality. This article is educational and is not a substitute for advice from your prescriber or pharmacist.

This preparation contains a controlled substance. Controlled-substance prescriptions carry refill limits, must be e-prescribed, and can only be shipped to states where Bayview holds the required licensure.

Uses discussed here may be off-label, meaning they are not part of any FDA-approved labeling. Off-label use is a decision for you and your prescriber, based on the available evidence.

Veterinary preparations are compounded to a veterinarian's order for a specific animal and are not FDA-approved animal drugs. Never give a compounded human medication to an animal without veterinary direction.

Standard
Cost & coverage

Compounded prescriptions are paid for directly rather than billed through insurance. Most are HSA/FSA-eligible, and many patients submit the receipt to their plan for possible reimbursement. Pricing depends on the strength, dose form and quantity your prescriber orders. Read more about cost and insurance.

Sildenafil Tablets and Tadalafil Tablets share one price schedule at Bayview: 30 tablets for $30, 60 for $37 and 90 for $48, in every strength. Patients enrolled in Auto Refills save 15% on every fill.

Bayview Pharmacy is a compounding pharmacy in Warwick, Rhode Island, licensed to fill and ship compounded prescriptions for patients in Rhode Island, Massachusetts, Connecticut, New Jersey, New Hampshire, Florida, Maine and Pennsylvania. Prescriptions for New York patients are filled on a limited basis, and controlled substances are not shipped to New York addresses. See every state we ship to.

Related reading

Reviewing pharmacist
Reviewed by
Ryan Dyer, RPh.
Ryan D. Dyer, RPh, is the founder and Pharmacist in Charge of Bayview Pharmacy, with more than 20 years of experience in pharmaceutical compounding. His expertise includes patient-specific formulation development, dosage-form design, sterile compounding under USP <797>, and quality systems supporting contemporary compounding practice.
Article by
The Bayview Team

Related Articles

Explore some of our recent blog articles below.

A Bayview Pharmacy vial of sildenafil tablets on a clinic desk with a physician e-prescribing behind it
4 min read

Prescribing sildenafil tablets: strengths, patient pricing, and how to send the prescription

A prescriber reference for sildenafil tablets through Bayview: strengths, labeled dosing and adjustments, the single patient price schedule, how to send the prescription, and next-line options.
A man taking a capsule at breakfast beside a container of compounded enclomiphene from Bayview Pharmacy
4 min read

Erectile dysfunction and low testosterone: how they connect

How low testosterone relates to erectile dysfunction, how it is tested, and the options a prescriber may consider alongside sildenafil or tadalafil, including enclomiphene, clomiphene and testosterone.
A man reviewing an instruction sheet with a urology clinician, a Bayview Pharmacy compounded trimix vial on the desk
4 min read

When ED tablets don't work: what prescribers try next

Why sildenafil or tadalafil sometimes falls short, what prescribers adjust first, and how injections such as trimix and urethral gels fit when tablets are not enough.